Colin Firth Movie:

		List Price: $14.98		Label: Hallmark Salesrank: 23096 Released: May 21, 2002
		Our Price: $75.99
		Used Price: $38.98
		MPAA Rating: PG (Parental Guidance Suggested) Media: DVD

The Secret Garden (Hallmark Hall of Fame) Reviews:
Not bad for a change....
2009-11-27 - Below I compare and contrast the three color adaptations.


1. The 1975 adaptation BBC

This adaptation is very low budgeted, and it shows in the picture quality, which is painful even if you are used to BBC 4.3 aspect ratio films. This said, the film is quite good in every other way if loyalty in plot is important to you. For example, Mr. Archibald Craven is given a larger role in this adaptation than in the 1987 and 1993 adaptations. Furthermore, a considerably amount of the dialogue is taken directly from the novel. Therefore, this adaptation is much less 'sound bites' and allows for the development of Mary, Dickon, and Collin's characters.

The acting is also considerably better than the 1987 and 1993 adaptations. Unfortunately, with child actors of probably 10 or 11 years of age who have memorize a large amount of script, errors will be evident.

Yet, the 1975 adaptation is the best adaptation. It is neither too mystical (1993) nor too gothic (1987).


2. The 1987 adaptation Hallmark

Although I know many individuals despise this adaptation, I enjoyed it for a change. Yes, the acting is not perfect and the accents are horrible. Yes, the ending is pathetic and quite changed from the novel. Yes, Dickon (as an adult) dies in World War I. Yet, when one considers what the film was trying to achieve (i.e. change the theme from a children's story to a social critique of problems in society), it does an effective job. The film is a little too gothic (in the Victorian literature definition -i.e. 'ghosts' and long, dark corridors), yet I did not think the gothic harmed the story but rather created a sense of anticipation.

Again, if you want a loyal adaptation, I would urge the the 1975 adaptation. However, if you are tired of watching the 1975 adaptation and want to see a change, in my opinion, this 1987 adaptation is a better choice than the 1993 adaptation.

(However, I am not certain I would pay more than $15.00 for the 1987 adaptation. Therefore, I do not own it on DVD - just VHS taped off the television when it aired sometime in the 1990s.)


3. The 1993 adaptation Time Warner

I really hated this adaptation - saw it once years ago and really have no desire to see it again, except maybe to improve my review at some later date. My first problem was that Mary's parents were killed in an earthquake rather than a plague. (I am not certain what this proved?). Secondly, the mystical music was annoying as were the inappropriate accents - although of the two, I could tolerate the poor accents much more than the poor music.

Additionally, other scenes were also altered. For example, Mary finds the key to the garden in her deceased aunt's bedroom in the shut up wing of the Manor. In the 1975 adaptation (and I think the 1987 adaptation also), Mary finds the key buried with some help from a robin. However, the robin does show Mary where the door to the garden is located.

Unfortunately, the other problem I have with this film is that it is centered almost exclusively on Mary's character. Where the 1975 adaptation provides other characters (ex: Martha, Dr. Craven, Sir Archibald Craven, and Martha's mother have with numerous scenes in which Mary does not appear.) In the Warner adaptation, Mary is the focus of nearly every scene.

Also, Collin's character was considerably altered into less dictatorial that in the novel the other film adaptations. In fact, at times, Collin appears very childish and timid - terrified of dying and of Mrs. Medlock (rather than bossing Mrs. Medlock, his nurse, and everyone else around).

Of course, I could add other details. I will not because I do not remember everything about the 1993 adaptation. Sufficient to say, I do not recommend it.

Secret Garden
2009-09-12 - I'm a fan of the English actor Colin Firth, so I bought this film. He makes a very short appearence at the end of the movie, and thats all. The movie is sweet, Colins appearence way too short.

Well Done!
2009-08-06 - I received the product earlier than I expected, and in the condition that was promised. I was very I happy with all the results and the purchase process.

Fast Shipping
2009-05-20 - I order this video as a birthday gift and I order it about seven or less days before the B-day. It arrived about three days early and it was in good condition.

Hands Down the Best Version
2009-05-04 - I can remember watching and taping this when it was originally released on television, and it has been one of my favorite videos since. I was so pleased to find the DVD as I had been told it was discontinued. I have seen the other versions of the Secret Garden and have always been disappointed. This is by far the truest adaptation of the book and in my opinion the most enjoyable. The acting is superb, the relationships well done, and the setting breathtaking. Some people have complained about the framing of the movie (Mary comes back as and adult in the beginning and marries Colin in the end - a departure form the book) but I think it is tastefully done and not enough to warrant censure from even the most devoted book fans. This is far superior to the tacky over the top 90's version and is more timeless than the original. This is sure to remain in my collection and to be shared with my children for years to come.