Kate Winslet Movie:

		List Price: $19.95		Label: The Weinstein Company Salesrank: 541 Released: April 14, 2009
		Our Price: $9.78
		Used Price: $6.99
		MPAA Rating: R (Restricted) Media: DVD

Editorial Review:
The Reader, set in post-WWII Germany, follows teenager Michael Berg as he engages in a passionate but secretive affair with an older woman named Hanna. Eight years after Hanna s disappearance, Michael is stunned to discover her again as she stands on trial for Nazi war crimes. The Reader is a haunting story about truth and reconciliation and how one generation comes to terms with the crimes of another. Kate Winslet won and Academy Award and a Golden Globe for her performance.

Description of The Reader:
What is the nature of guilt--and how can the human spirit survive when confronted with deep and horrifying truths? The Reader, a hushed and haunting meditation on these knotty questions, is sorrowful and shocking, yet leavened by a deep love story that is its heart. In postwar Germany, young schoolboy Michael (German actor David Cross) meets and begins a tender romance with the older, mysterious Hanna (Kate Winslet, whose performance is a revelation). The two make love hungrily in Hanna's shabby apartment, yet their true intimacy comes as Michael reads aloud to Hanna in bed, from his school assignments, textbooks, even comic books. Hanna delights in the readings, and Michael delights in Hanna.

Years later, the two cross paths again, and Michael (played as an adult by Ralph Fiennes) learns, slowly, horrifyingly, of acts that Hanna may have been involved in during the war. There is a war crimes trial, and the accused at one point asks the panel of prosecutors: "Well, what would you have done?" It is that question--as one German professor says later: "How can the next generation of Germans come to terms with the Holocaust?"--that is both heartbreaking and unanswerable. Winslet plays every shade of gray in her portrayal of Hanna, and Fiennes is riveting as the man who must rewrite history--his own and his country's--as he learns daily, hourly, of deeds that defy categorization, and morality. "No matter how much washing and scrubbing," one character says matter of factly, "some sins don't wash away." The Reader (with nods to similar films like Sophie's Choice and The English Patient dares to present that unnerving premise, without offering an easy solution. --A.T. Hurley

The Reader Reviews:
forgiving people their sins
2009-11-26 - Twenty and more years since a young and illiterate woman was an SS guard,
she is put on trial. Christianity is the basis of most western morality
that has become law, but forgiving people hasn't made it past the 2000
years of civilization since Jesus? Did this woman take advantage of the 15 year old boy
or did he take advantage of her? When he held the key to her
being delivered from an unjust prison sentence, he withheld the knowledge he had
because it would have brought out his shame?
Who were the victims, those who died a relatively quick death
in the camps or the people who had to live long lives knowing what they had done?
This film makes more questions than can be answered.
One mad monster of a man drove a nation to inhumanity
with his speeches and millions of Jews died as a result.
I think maybe that taking revenge on guards in the camps
is not a Christian act, even if entirely legal.

The Sick Result of Gender Fascism
2009-11-16 - I hope that all those who give this film a positive review would be equally enthusiastic about the story of an ex-SS soldier and his repeated statutory rape and subsequent desertion of a 15 year old girl. Western society's pseudo-equality, presented in its most exaggerated form in Hollywood, states that the crimes of women, especially the good-looking ones, are to be forgiven and are nowhere near as bad as the identical crimes committed by men. This is because women have feelings, even war criminals involved in genocide, while men are creatures devoid of them and deserve their full punishment.

Throughout the film, Winslet's character shows not the slightest sign of remorse that she helped burn people alive, and merely tries to give excuses. At one point, she asks the ridiculous question to the judge 'What would you have done?'. This from a woman who volunteered for the SS to work in concentration camps, which only the mentally challenged could have had any doubts about even during the war. Yes, say that to one of the German Wehrmacht's poor conscripts who were uprooted from family and home for military service, or faced a concentration camp for draft-dodging. But please don't say that about someone who as a woman could have spent the war sitting pretty in her factory job, but chose to make extra money by working at Auschwitz.

Apart from showing not the slightest sign of remorse for her part in the Holocaust, she has the audacity to commit child abuse on a 15 year old child, using him for her selfish ends and then dumping him when she'd had enough. What he sees in the miserable, unloving, haggard woman is beyond comprehension. But would fans of this film watch an equally well-made film of the repeated statutory rape of a girl with equal enthusiasm? Or has Hollywood's gender fascism really blunted the intellects and moral sensibilities of so many?

Should we really feel sorry for her excessive sentence for not admitting she couldn't write? Certainly not. We should see it as an example of the damaging effects of having an ego so massive, of being so swollen-headed and vain that one would rather get life imprisonment than admit one's failures. Pathetic. (But then again, this could never have happened in reality. Every SS applicant had a mountain of papers and forms to fill in and illiterates then wouldn't have got much further than your average applicant for the police force today. More Hollywood fantasy.)

The woman was lucky she wasn't prosecuted directly after the war when war criminals were still executed, which is what she definitely deserved. Instead, she got away with life imprisonment, something the 600 poor women she enjoyed burning alive would have done anything for. Kate Winslet and her young co-star do a good job playing these roles, no question. But this film is fundamentally, morally flawed, and is not only hated by all Holocaust survivors for good reason. It's increasingly hated by those who see the perversion of justice that results when we say that murder and child abuse committed by a woman are not as as bad as the identical crimes committed by a man.

No easy answers, but very easy to get immersed
2009-11-13 - This beautifully acted and shot film is laced with complex characterizations and complex emotional situations, making it a breath of fresh air in today's increasingly simple cinematic landscape. Thematically, the movie doesn't necessarily say that people should find a way to forgive or look beyond horrific acts a friend or loved one may have committed, only to make us understand why some people might do so. To that end, the movie demonstrates how one's personal experience with someone will often trump how we "should" feel about that person, even if it's clear that the person did some terrible things. The movie also functions as a methaphor for German society in the post-World War II years, where young Germans were repelled by what their parents and other respected elders did during the war, but yet simply couldn't shun and abandon them. "The Reader" looks spectacular on standard DVD (the image sports a perfect balance between sharpness and warmth) and there's a generous array of special features that further illuminate the thoughtful, emotional story. Definitely for mature audiences, "The Reader" is highly recommended for a night when you're in the mood for something a cut above mere time-passing entertainment.

A realistic view of the German dilemma.
2009-11-11 - The Reader is a film made in Germany, by Germans and reflects a more accurate view of German attitudes than anything that has ever come out of Hollywood. It may not be what Americans have stored in their stereotypical vision of Germans being repentent and contrite after the war, but the Xenophobia and yearning for Lebensraum is still there in the hearts and minds of many Germans.
The acting in the movie is superb and caused the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences to award an Oscar to Kate Winslet, but the acting must be based on truth rather than fantasy. This is film is NOT fantasy, it is history brought to the world's attention.

very good
2009-10-13 - it was a movie in which you could not help but think about it and analyze it for a couple of days.